When a business makes unusually high profits, other companies notice and try to take a share. Usually they succeed, and the profits shrink back to normal. Some businesses resist this for decades. The thing that protects them is called an economic moat, after the water-filled ditch that kept attackers away from a castle.

This article is general information, not personal financial advice.

Where the idea comes from

The term was popularised by Warren Buffett, who has run the investment company Berkshire Hathaway since the 1960s. In his 2007 letter to shareholders he set out the idea plainly. A truly great business, he wrote, must have an enduring moat that protects excellent returns on the money invested in it. Competitors will keep attacking any business “castle” that earns high returns, so a strong barrier is essential if success is to last.

He gave two examples of such barriers: being the lowest-cost producer, as with the car insurer GEICO and the retailer Costco, and owning a powerful worldwide brand, as with Coca-Cola, Gillette and American Express.

The five sources of a moat

The investment research firm Morningstar turned the idea into a rating system. Its analysts look for five sources of moat:

Each works differently.

Switching costs. Think of software that a company’s staff are trained on and its records are stored in. A rival may be cheaper, but moving means retraining people and transferring data, with the risk that something breaks. Many customers stay put even when they are unhappy.

Network effects. A marketplace attracts buyers because the sellers are there, and sellers because the buyers are. A payment card is worth carrying because shops accept it, and shops accept it because people carry it. Once a network is large, a newcomer struggles to offer the same value.

Intangible assets. A patent gives a drug maker the legal right to be the only seller of a medicine for a period. A licence may be required to operate at all. A trusted brand lets a company charge more for a product that rivals can copy in substance.

Cost advantage. A company that can make or deliver something more cheaply than anyone else can win on price or earn more on each sale. The advantage may come from size, location, a better process or access to a cheap resource.

Efficient scale. Some markets have room for only one or two profitable firms, such as an airport or a pipeline serving one region. A newcomer would split the business and leave everyone unprofitable, so few try.

How long a moat lasts

Morningstar rates companies on how long their advantage is likely to hold. A wide moat is one expected to last more than 20 years. A narrow moat is expected to fend off rivals for about ten. A company with no moat has no advantage, or one that will quickly disappear. The firm also tracks whether each company’s moat is getting stronger or weaker.

The time dimension is the point. Almost any business can earn high profits for a while. A moat is about whether it can keep doing so.

How long Morningstar expects each kind of moat to lastYears of competitive advantage
How long Morningstar expects each kind of moat to last
ItemYears of competitive advantage
Wide moatMore than 20 years
Narrow moatAbout 10 years

A company with no moat has no lasting advantage.Source: Morningstar. Chart: The Sidelight.

How moats are lost

Buffett described companies whose advantage turned out to be illusory as “Roman Candles”: bright for a moment, then gone. He said Berkshire avoids industries prone to rapid and continuous change, because a moat that must constantly be rebuilt will in the end be no moat at all. He added that competitive change is good for society, but makes the future of any single company uncertain.

Moats can be lost in several ways:

  • Technology changes the rules. A new way of doing things can make an old advantage irrelevant, as when an established product is replaced by a different kind of product altogether.
  • Patents expire. Once they do, rivals can legally copy the product.
  • Regulation changes. A licence can be withdrawn, or a market opened to competition.
  • The brand is damaged. Trust built over decades can be lost quickly.
  • Management squanders it. A company that raises prices too far, or neglects its product, invites customers to try alternatives.

Buffett also warned against mistaking a talented individual for a moat. A medical practice led by a region’s best surgeon may earn outsized profits, he wrote, but its advantage leaves when the surgeon does. He contrasted it with the Mayo Clinic, whose reputation lasts though few people could name its chief executive.

How to recognise one

There is no single test, but some questions help.

  1. Has the company earned high returns for a long time? A moat should show up in the numbers over many years, not one or two.
  2. Could it raise prices without losing many customers? Pricing power is one of the clearest signs of an advantage.
  3. What would a well-funded rival need to compete? If the answer is just money, the moat may be shallow.
  4. Which of the five sources applies? If none clearly does, high profits may be temporary.
  5. Is the industry changing fast? Rapid change, on Buffett’s argument, makes any advantage harder to keep.

Moats and competition

There is a tension in the idea. What an investor calls a moat, a customer may experience as having no real choice. Strong network effects and high switching costs can make a market less competitive, and competition authorities such as the UK’s Competition and Markets Authority examine markets where a few firms hold lasting power. A moat built on a better or cheaper product benefits customers. One built on making it hard to leave is less welcome to them.

For anyone assessing a business, as an investor, an employee or a founder, the useful question is the same: what stops someone else doing this, and how long will that last?