There are two ways to run an investment fund. An active fund employs a manager who chooses which shares or bonds to hold, aiming to do better than the market. An index fund, also called a passive fund or tracker, simply holds everything in a market index such as the FTSE 100 and aims to match it. The first costs more than the second. The question for investors is whether the extra cost buys a better result, and the evidence so far says that on average it does not.

This article is general information, not personal financial advice.

What happened in 2025

The longest-running scorecard is published by S&P Dow Jones Indices, a company that compiles market indices. Twice a year it compares active funds with a benchmark, the index that represents the market each fund invests in. Its report for 2025 covers funds based in Europe.

Fund categoryUnderperformed
UK equity, broad88%
UK large and mid-sized companies89%
UK smaller companies97%
Global equity, priced in sterling75%
European equity, priced in sterling78%
UK government bonds59%
Share of active funds that underperformed their benchmark in 2025

Across Europe, most active funds underperformed in 18 of the 21 equity categories S&P reports. Bond funds did better. Most sterling corporate bond funds beat their benchmark.

The UK figures were unusually bad. S&P’s analyst described them as “historic”, ranking among the worst two or three years in a record going back 14 years. These funds did not lose money. Most made gains. They made less than the index.

Share of active funds that trailed their benchmark in 2025% of funds
Share of active funds that trailed their benchmark in 2025
Item% of funds
UK smaller companies97%
UK large and mid-sized89%
UK equity, broad88%
European equity, sterling78%
Global equity, sterling75%
UK government bonds59%

Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Europe. Chart: The Sidelight.

Why most active funds fall short

The first reason is arithmetic. Before costs, the average of all investors’ returns must equal the market’s return, because together they are the market. After costs, the average must be lower. Active funds charge more, so as a group they start behind.

The second is that a few shares often drive the market. S&P’s analysis of 2025 found that the gains in UK indices came from a small number of companies, and that shares doing much worse than the index outnumbered those doing much better by more than two to one. A manager who did not own the handful of winners, in at least the same proportion as the index, was likely to fall behind. Picking shares at random was more likely to hurt than help.

Before costs, the average of all investors’ returns must equal the market’s return. After costs, it must be lower.”

What the regulator found

One source has a commercial interest in the answer: S&P sells indices. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the UK regulator, does not, and it reached a similar conclusion from its own data. Its Asset Management Market Study found:

  • on average, both actively managed and passively managed funds did not outperform their own benchmarks after fees
  • there was no clear relationship between what an active fund charged and how well it performed before fees
  • there was some evidence that higher charges went with worse returns after fees
  • firms in its sample made average profit margins of 36%, and active charges had stayed broadly stable for ten years
  • around £109 billion sat in “active” funds that closely mirrored the market while charging significantly more than passive funds

The first finding cuts both ways. An index fund will also trail its index, by roughly the amount it charges. The difference is that the shortfall is small and predictable.

The FCA was careful to say it was not telling investors that passive funds are preferable. Its point was that investors should understand the total cost and what a fund is trying to do. The study dates from 2017, so the detail is old, though S&P’s more recent results point the same way.

Can you pick the winners in advance?

Some active funds do beat the index, in every year. The difficulty is identifying them beforehand. The FCA concluded that past performance “is not likely to be a good indicator of future performance”. It found little evidence that outperformance persists, and said that where persistence exists, it tends to be persistently poor performance.

Records also flatter the survivors. The FCA noted that the worst-performing funds were more likely to be closed or merged into others. The funds you can see today are the ones that lasted.

What a difference in charges does over time

Charges are taken every year, on the whole pot, whether or not the fund does well. The effect compounds. The example below uses assumed figures to show the scale. It is an illustration, not a forecast, and the charges are examples, not market averages.

Annual chargeValue after 20 years
0.15%£25,785
0.90%£22,336
£10,000 invested for 20 years at 5% a year before charges

In this example the cheaper fund ends about £3,450 ahead, a third of the original sum, from a difference of 0.75 percentage points a year. An active fund has to beat the market by more than its extra cost, every year on average, just to draw level.

The case for active funds

The evidence above is about averages, and there are fair arguments on the other side.

  • Some markets are harder to index. S&P’s own figures show active bond funds doing better than active equity funds, and most sterling corporate bond funds beat their benchmark in 2025.
  • Index funds buy everything. They hold overvalued companies along with the rest, and a fund tracking an index dominated by a few very large companies is less diversified than it looks.
  • Someone has to set prices. Markets work because active investors research companies and trade on what they find. If everyone tracked an index, nobody would be doing that.
  • Goals differ. A fund may aim to limit losses or pay a steady income, not to beat an index.

What would change this conclusion

The case against paying for active management rests on its results after costs. It would weaken if active charges fell close to index-fund levels, or if scorecards began to show most active funds beating their benchmarks over long periods and not just in odd years. Neither has happened yet.

For someone choosing a fund, the practical points are few. Find the total annual charge. Check what index the fund is measured against and whether it has beaten it after charges over ten years or more, not one. Be wary of choosing on recent performance alone. A regulated financial adviser can advise on your own circumstances, which this article cannot.